Skip to Content

Gel vs. Liquid vs. Pencil Eyeliner: Which is Better?

Gel vs. Liquid vs. Pencil Eyeliner: Which is Better?

When it comes to eyeliners, there are three different types to choose from. You can choose between the gel eyeliner, the liquid eyeliner, and the pencil eyeliner. Which one is the best to use? What is the difference between the three eyeliners?

These are all questions that women are asking about eyeliners. So many are making mistakes when applying eyeliner because they are choosing the wrong one. This is everything you need to know about the different eyeliners so that you can choose the right one.

Gel vs Liquid Eyeliner

Gel versus liquid eyeliner. Which one is the better option, and what is the difference between these two?  Before you can know which one, is the better option for you, you need to know what the difference between these two really is.

Liquid eyeliner is the one that most are using. This is the eyeliner that looks like pens and that has a liquid form that you are using. It is waterier and can make a mistake really easily if you don’t know how to use eyeliner correctly. However, it gives a great effect, if you apply it correctly.

The gel eyeliner is not as popular to use. It is harder to apply and to get an even line over your eyes. This is the reason why not many people are using it. It is in a gel form, and you need to have a small brush to apply it correctly. The great thing about the gel is that you can control how much you are using, and how thick the line is going to be, by using different brush sizes.

Which one is best for a novice makeup user?

Which eyeliner is going to be best for the novice or beginner makeup user? Should you use the gel eyeliner, the liquid eyeliner or the pencil eyeliner?

For the best results as a beginner without any chance of making mistakes, the best eyeliner to use is a pencil. It still gives you great results, but it isn’t as hard to apply as the gel or liquid eyeliner. Mistakes can also correct easier than the other two options.

More: Hypoallergenic Eyeliners

Which is better gel eyeliner or liquid?

You know by now the difference between the gel eyeliner and the liquid eyeliner. The question is which one is better to use? Most of the time the liquid eyeliner is waterproof, while the gel eyeliner isn’t waterproof. There are only a few of the gel eyeliners that are known to be waterproof.

This is making the liquid eyeliner a much better option. Especially, if you are looking for something that will last throughout the day, even during the heat. The gel is a great option, but liquid eyeliner is a much better choice for better, long-lasting results.

Liquid vs Pencil Eyeliner

The difference between the liquid eyeliner and the pencil eyeliner. Both can be waterproof, and long-lasting depending on the type of eyeliner that you are purchasing. Both are really popular and are available everywhere. But, what is the difference between these two types of eyeliners?

As we said before the liquid eyeliner is a pen-like eyeliner with liquid and watery eyeliner that you are applying. It can be messy if you don’t know how to apply it correctly, or if you are purchasing a cheap type of eyeliners.

The pencil eyeliner is the eyeliner that looks like a pencil. You are getting different colors, different thicknesses and some are easier to apply than others. Some of the cheaper pencils are really hard to apply because you can’t see it on your eyes as easily. Normally the pencil is cheaper than the liquid eyeliner, but the liquid one is more durable and long-lasting.

What is the Easiest Type of Eyeliner to Apply?

Between the gel, liquid and pencil eyeliner, which one is the easiest one to apply. The first thing that comes to mind might be a pencil because most beginners are using it. However, this doesn’t mean that this is the easiest one to use, in general.

There are many pencil eyeliners that are hard to apply. They don’t work correctly and can smudge easily while you are applying it as well. The same goes for the gel. If you don’t use the right brush and apply the right amount, this is going to be hard to apply it correctly. So, the easiest type of eyeliner to apply is liquid eyeliner. You will always get the look you want with the liquid.

Is liquid eyeliner better?

As mentioned before, yes, the liquid eyeliner is much better than the gel eyeliner and a pencil. Especially, if you had some practice with the liquid.

It is much easier to apply, won’t smudge as easy and will give a smooth, solid line. With a pencil, you can struggle to get a visible line if you are using a cheap pencil, and the gel can make uneven lines. Studies have shown that most women prefer to use liquid eyeliner over any other type of eyeliner. Even if they need to practice to get the line straight.

Does gel or liquid eyeliner last longer

We are always looking for the eyeliner that lasts the longest. A question that we are getting all the time, is if the gel or liquid eyeliner lasts the longest. In order to understand this, there are a couple of things that you should consider.

  • First of all, it depends on the type of eyeliner that you are purchasing. Automatically, the more expensive eyeliner will last longer. No matter if this is the gel or liquid eyeliner.
  • Studies have shown that people are stating that gel eyeliners are lasting longer if you are applying it correctly.
  • Some are saying that liquid eyeliner is better and lasts a lot longer than gel eyeliner because it is drying better than the gel.

At the end of the day, it depends on the quality of the eyeliner, and the way that you are applying it. For some, the liquid will last longer, while for other the gel will last longer. It is something that will depend on personal preferences.

If you want to use an eyeliner that is lasting the longest, the best is to use them both and to see for yourself which one is the better one for you. And, which one is going to last longest.

pencil vs Liquid Eyeliner

How to choose the Right Eyeliner

Knowing the difference between liquid, gel and pencil eyeliner isn’t the only thing that you should know about. You should also make sure that you know how to choose the right one for you. At the end of the day, it doesn’t matter if you know what other people prefer. You need to use the one that is best for you and you alone. Here are some tips on how you should choose the right one for you.

  • Are you a beginner in using eyeliner? Then you should start with a pencil. It is the easiest to use.
  • To create the best-looking cat-eye, liquid eyeliner is the best one to use. It creates the smoothest and darkest lines.
  • If you want to be in control of how thick or thin the line needs to be, then the gel eyeliner is for you. You are using a brush to add the eyeliner. You can choose how thick or thin the brush should be.

Gel, liquid and pencil eyeliner in short: What we have learned

The pencil eyeliner is the easiest one to use if you are purchasing a high-quality pencil that is making lines easy and dark. If you are experienced in doing makeup, then you can try using the gel eyeliner.

Most people prefer using the liquid eyeliner because this is a versatile eyeliner that you can even use to create the best-looking cat-eye look. It is easy to apply, gives a smooth line and good quality liquid eyeliner doesn’t smudge that easily.

If you are looking to purchase your eyeliner, you should consider the one that will be best suited for you and the look that you want to create. And, you need to make sure that you are choosing a high-quality eyeliner that is waterproof and long-lasting to have the look throughout the day.

Even beginners can use eyeliner, but it is recommended that you should start with a pencil and then go to the liquid eyeliner. Because you are using a brush for the gel eyeliner, you need to have some experience before you can try them out.

The moment that you know more about the gel, liquid and pencil eyeliners, you will understand why some people are using the liquid eyeliner more than other people. And, why it is recommended that beginners are starting with a good quality pencil.

It is a great idea to try them all out and use the one that you are most comfortable with. This is the great thing about the eyeliners. With the variety of different kinds, you can choose the one that is best for you, and not struggle with something that you can’t use.