Skip to Content

6 Best Eyeshadow Primer Substitutes

6 Best Eyeshadow Primer Substitutes

Eyeshadow primer provides a base for eyeshadows to grip onto. It creates a matte, oil-free surface and makes an even skin-colored canvas for eyeshadow color to “pop”.

Anything else that does these things can be used as an eyeshadow primer. Alternatives include vaseline, concealer, powder, and pencil. You can also utilize aloe vera gel or lip gloss.

If you utilize a concealer, opt for water-proof stick concealers. Avoid oily concealers. The powder makes a great alternative for primer. However, it won’t help the eyeshadow color pop.

A white eyeliner pencil is another perfect option. Just blend, then utilize eyeshadow on top. You can also utilize a pencil that’s the color of your eyeshadow to give it extra “pop”.

Also Read: Substitute For Primer

Does Eyeshadow Need Primer?

It’s recommended to apply eyeshadow primer before applying eyeshadow. Otherwise, your makeup will begin to fade or move over time. And your eyelids will start to appear greasy.

Using a primer keeps oils from the skin away from the eyeshadow. It helps prevent smudging and fading. Primer is a must if you have oily eyelids. It will keep your shadow intact all day.

Eyeshadow Primer Substitutes

If you’re running low on eyeshadow primer, try one of the following substitutes. You would be surprised to learn what products can be utilized as an eyeshadow primer.

1. Aloe vera gel

Aloe vera gel does wonders for your face. And one of those wonders is priming your eyelids even better than actual eyeshadow primers. It moisturized your eyelids perfectly.

The best part? It doesn’t add oil. Thus, providing a flawless surface for eyeshadow to stay put during the day or night. Give it a few minutes to dry before applying your shades.

2. Concealer

Concealers have a lightweight and long-lasting formula. This is why they make a perfect alternative for a primer. Your eyeshadow will appear flawless throughout the day or night.

3. Highlighter

Highlighter can also be utilized as a base for your eyeshadow. It will keep the pigment in the kid and aid brighten and even apply some glow to your eyeshadow color.

4. Eyeliner pencil

Grab your favorite white eyeliner pencil that you haven’t used for ages and put it in use! Softly apply the pencil and blend. Once you’re done, apply your eyeshadow. The pencil will stay on without creasing and make your eyeshadow color brighter than ever!

5. Foundation

If you want to make a difference in your smokey eye routine, use foundation and powder. Apply liquid foundation and give it time to dry. Then, set with your favorite powder. Your eyelids will get the smooth surface to handle whatever you apply in them and won’t get oily.

6. Lip gloss

I know it sounds gross but it works! The stickiness of your favorite lip gloss will help the eyeshadow stay intact. It will add a little bit of natural shine to your eyelids, too!

Can You Use Vaseline as Eyeshadow Primer?

Absolutely! One function for petroleum jelly that I have overlooked is eyeshadow primer. Vaseline works in the same way cream eyeshadow or concealer do help eye makeup “pop”.

Can You Use Concealer as an Eye Primer?

You can utilize a concealer as an eyeshadow primer. However, make sure that your concealer gives you full or medium coverage. Also, set it with powder for smooth eyeshadow application.

How Do You Make Homemade Eyeshadow Primer?

I’m a fan of creating everything myself! Homemade eyeshadow primer will save you a few dollars you can spend on something else. The best part? It’s easy to make and provides great results.

Also, you have complete control over the ingredients that go into your DIY eyeshadow primer. The next recipe contains only three ingredients. It doesn’t contain artificial ingredients or chemicals.



Mix all the ingredients in a bowl. Place the paste in a container with a lid.

Store your eyeshadow primer in the fridge for up to 2 weeks. The consistency of the product will change as it sits in the refrigerator but it will still work well.

To utilize your DIY eyeshadow primer, grab a small amount, and place it onto your eyelids. Give it 15 to 30 seconds to dry. Then, apply your favorite eyeshadow.

How to Apply Eyeshadow Primer Properly?

Eyeshadow primer helps eyeshadows stick throughout the day or night without smudging and creasing. However, if you don’t have a primer on hand, use the following tricks.

Begin with a clean slate

Oily eyelids can cause your eyeshadows to melt off of your skin. Therefore, wash your face with a good cleanser and utilize oil-free makeup remover to remove any mascara leftovers. Or shadow from the day before. Always wash your face and take off your makeup before going to sleep.

Make a base

Concealers can be utilized for more than just providing a base under the eyes. It can also offer a clean base on the eyelids. You can also try the foundation. These beauty products will brighten up your whole eye area and help your eyeshadow stick. Also, don’t forget to set with powder.

You can use a dust translucent loose powder to keep your eyelids matte. This will also control oils during the day or night and provide a flawless surface for eyeshadow to adhere to.

Use a brush for applying eyeshadow

I know that you don’t want to spend money on eyeshadow brushes. But they’re worth the investment. They enable you to apply the eyeshadow in thin layers.

They also allow you to slowly build-up to the preferred tone. Putting your eyeshadow with a high-quality brush will make it last longer which isn’t the case with sponge applicators.

You can also utilize your fingers. But although they seem like a great blending tool, you risk adding extra oil and breaking down the pigment of the eyeshadow.

Extra tip: Always wash your eyeshadow brushes with soap and lukewarm water and let them dry fully in between uses to stop the buildup of bacteria.

Why Does my Eyeshadow Crease Even with Primer?

If you’re experiencing creasing even when using an eyeshadow primer, it could be because your eyeshadow is too sheer.

Makeup professionals recommend applying light layers of primer. Then, add the foundation. Finally, add a couple of layers of eyeshadow to prevent any movement.

What is the Difference Between Eye Primer and Concealer?

The concealer has a heavy formula. It’s utilized to conceal acne, pimples, scars, or tattoos. For example, mineral concealers help match your skin type and accomplish a flawless look.

Primer, on the other hand, is utilized before applying eye makeup. It has a lightweight formula and helps eyeshadow last longer. It prevents oiling and keeps your eye makeup intact.

Also Read: Primer Vs. Concealer

Can I Use Regular Primer on my Eyelids?

Utilizing face products close to your eyes isn’t recommended. It can cause sensitivity. Also, face primer is less effective at preventing oily eyelids and making your eye makeup last all day.

Can You Use Foundation as Eyeshadow Primer?

Absolutely! A super-thin layer of foundation can be used as an eyeshadow primer, however, don’t forget to set your work with a translucent setting powder to help set the foundation.

Final Words

Running out of a favorite beauty product is a nightmare for makeup freaks.

Whether your mascara dried up or you wasted the last drop of eyeshadow primer, you probably don’t have the time to rush to the store and buy a new product, especially if you’re in a hurry.

However, don’t worry. I have a solution or two or six for you! You already own some eyeshadow primer alternatives. You can use a concealer, vaseline, powder, white eyeliner pencil, or lip gloss.

I often use a soft white eyeliner. You can also utilize your regular face primer. Simply pat a small amount over your eyelids. Also, don’t forget to set with powder or a neutral shadow.


Friday 9th of July 2021

What brand of eyeliner / eyeshadow for someone with allergies , it always falls off because only one eye always waters but I’ve noticed it doesn’t stay on the other eye either super frustrating